Real Solutions or New Age Fantasies?

Today's Bermuda Sun editorial page is a lesson in contrasts. On the one hand you have Larry Burchall proposing common sense crime fighting solutions. While I object to his "underclass" frame, the underlying point is spot on when he writes, "The only real and possible action here is defensive. More police action, more jail cells, and longer sentences so that the people in this underclass are put away and then kept in human warehouses - prisons. That process buys serial peace. Each time one is released, we have to wait for him to act violently again; or we have to find a new pretext for re-warehousing him."

It's not more police - it's more police ACTION, and, it's up to the Governor to make that happen. Compare Burchall's comman sense approach to Stuart Hayward's new age, head in the clouds fantasy. "It should be noted that celebrities as different as entertainer Oprah Winfry (sic) and film director David Lynch have got behind using Transcendental Meditation (TM) as an effective means of cooling down the emotional temperature in schools and communities. Research over the last forty or more years has proven TM effective for reducing stress while increasing mental and physical performance."

I'd like to see Stuart's "research." Please, someone, cite some research that suggests TRANSCENDENTAL MEDITATION is a solution for combating gang violence. Helping Oprah and David Lynch find their "inner selves" is one thing. Solving the crime problem requires common sense solutions, new age head in the clouds fantasies.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

try something new

"Common sense solutions", i.e. more effective policing, seem to be all that anyone can muster up when events like this occur, but it does nothing to curb individuals' DESIRE to behave the way they have been. the real solution lies in combating what drives this anti-social behavior in the first place. although it sounds nice, does anyone really feel that more 'on the beat' police officers will prevent violence? The resulting violence may be less brazen, but if someone wants to kill or seriously injure a fellow Bermudian, he will find a way to do it whether or not there is a police officer on every street corner. I cannot see how the police can commit more ACTION in cases like this if Bermuda's culture of keeping your mouth shut when the police ask questions doesn't change.

Given the apparent culture inside our public high schools (most notably the recent gang violence), I think that is the perfect place to start. Gang members in general are pretty young, and there are undoubtedly current and future gang members roaming the halls today. I'm not going to pretend that I have the answers for tackling this culture, but I do know that it won't be as simple as better policing. That's just lazy ideology and deflects accountability away from those who responsible for shaping these individuals and gangs.

I'm not sure what effect TM would have on the development of Bermuda's youth, but I doubt it would be a bad thing and I 100% agree that the schools is where this cultural problem needs to be addressed. By the time it makes it to the street it is already too late. Locking people up for longer periods also seems crude and overly simple. If people are not worried about the punishment this sort of behavior warrants already, I doubt increasing it is going to make any difference. The thing is, I don't imagine any of these guys plan on getting caught. One law I would support is one that makes gang membership a criminal offense, as it is something that is easy to identify (anyone around magistrates court last week can attest to that).

p.s. its cite... not site.

resources question

In a perfect world, we would do everything, including TM. But, it's not a perfect world. We have limited resources and have to make choices. I think your call for more community policing is key and is exactly what the Premier was advocating for in his meeting with the Governor.

Community policing = yes. School-based interventions = yes. Crazy new age methods = imagine how aghast the UBP would be if the PLP government proposed spending big to bring in meditation experts to Bermuda. If Stuart really cared about this issue, perhaps he would offer some TM seminars at our schools to test it's effectiveness. I doubt he will.

Spin with malice or ignorance?

@ Rocksolid - I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt, and assume it's just a coincidence, but using the term Governor General is at best just wrong, and at worst yet ANOTHER attempt of a coordinated piece of spin by the PLP.

For those that don't know:
The term Governor General or Governor-General refers to a vice-regal representative of a Monarch in an independent realm.

whereas we have a Governor:
In the United Kingdom's remaining overseas territories the governor is normally a direct appointee of the British Government and plays an active role in governing and lawmaking (though usually with the advice of elected local representatives). The Governor's chief responsibility is for the Defence and External Affairs of the colony.

Once again, just trying to slip a word of truth into the spin-cycle, lest people view and use this site as anything more than propoganda.

Laughing Out Loud

Ry, I'm thoroughly impressed with your ability to spin wild conspiracy theories. It's quite a talent. A correction has been appended.

I'm glad you're impressed

But Governor General is a pretty specific term. It's not like you mispelt it or something. And it's language both yourself and the PLP.bm blogger are using.

So if not a coordinated effort - a coincidence?

Link?

Would love to see where PLP.bm used it. Can you please provide a link?

Wow...new lows

So I didn't think you'd stoop this low - yes you've successfully changed the blog entry since the 'mistake' was pointed out to you. Just because you've updated it, doesn't mean that it didn't once exist. As of this time yesterday (on the 28th of May) the PLP blog read:

"Today, Premier Ewart Brown, Deputy Premier Paula Cox and Minister David Burch met with the Governor General to discuss crime."

Of course, since this has been called out, the kind blogger and yourself have ammended your articles.

So yes, thank you for changing it, but please don't act smug as if it never existed - that's just pathetic.

Real Lows

No, Ry, it's you that's spinning up wild conspiracy theories and making bizarre allegations. I acknowledged an error and corrected it in the post. What, pray tell, is wrong about that? I'd really like to know.

Would you like me to start quoting things (accurately or not) from the UBP website and start blaming you for them?

Everything Should Be on the Table

This Social Ill must be dealt with head on, point blank! No political persuasions, ideologues, pundits or columnists have the sole answers and if anything, it is just half bastardized approaches at best (i.e. TM). And this is directed to the general comments I hear and read. I agree to the actions the Governor and Police Commissioner are taking but this is only a knee jerk reaction. Our police force need to get tough on gang violence and our politicians need to review and change the law books. I am for longer sentences for repeated offenders, drug violators and especially murderers. In the same breath, I would say we need to improve/add rehabilitation programs that can go many lengths to improve troubled individuals.

We need to also, as a community, work on our roles in improving society. Like mentioned above, we got to stamp this ill out from the youth. We must do it in the home, schools, and the wider environment because the little attitudes and misdemeanors that come from "we adults," are analyzed, sponged into and acted out by the young. In my opinion, there should be a "Big Conversation" on this issue before it really becomes out of hand and solutions are harder to seek. We need to brain-storm solutions mostly on social influences that galvanizes negative experiences.

On this issue, everything needs to be on the table-there is no time for passiveness.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.